Which court case involved a physician found guilty of failing to obtain informed consent by not divulging the full extent of his experience after the patient asked specifically?

Which court case involved a physician found guilty of failing to obtain informed consent by not divulging the full extent of his experience after the patient asked specifically?

• A. Johnson v Kokemoor
• B. Brown v Board of Education
• C. Roe v Wade
• D. Miranda v Arizona

Answer: (A)

Informed consent isn’t just about agreeing to a procedure after hearing risks; it also requires that a patient be given meaningful information about who will perform it and that the doctor’s qualifications and experience be disclosed when relevant. If a patient directly asks about the surgeon’s experience and the physician withholds or downplays that information, the patient isn’t fully informed to weigh the decision, which can render the consent invalid and expose the clinician to liability. Johnson v Kokemoor centers on this idea: a physician failed to disclose the full extent of his experience when the patient specifically asked, and the court treated that lack of disclosure as a failure to obtain proper informed consent. The other listed cases deal with very different issues—desegregation, abortion rights, and police interrogation rights—and do not address medical consent or disclosure of a physician’s qualifications.

Informed consent isn’t just about agreeing to a procedure after hearing risks; it also requires that a patient be given meaningful information about who will perform it and that the doctor’s qualifications and experience be disclosed when relevant. If a patient directly asks about the surgeon’s experience and the physician withholds or downplays that information, the patient isn’t fully informed to weigh the decision, which can render the consent invalid and expose the clinician to liability.

Johnson v Kokemoor centers on this idea: a physician failed to disclose the full extent of his experience when the patient specifically asked, and the court treated that lack of disclosure as a failure to obtain proper informed consent. The other listed cases deal with very different issues—desegregation, abortion rights, and police interrogation rights—and do not address medical consent or disclosure of a physician’s qualifications.